More young Arabs see China as an ally of their countries than the United States, a survey of regional youth has found.
The U.S. ranks seventh among nations considered as friendly, compared to China, which ranked second in the Arab Youth Survey conducted by Dubai-based public relations firm ASDA’A BCW.
The findings show that support for China has gradually risen over the years as Beijing expands its footprint in the region. But they also reveal that as much as Arabs want the U.S. to play a smaller role in the Middle East, many believe the superpower will continue to be the most influential actor.
Eighty percent of respondents consider China to be an ally of their country, while 72 percent found the U.S. to be one. Support for both countries has grown from last year, when the U.S. stood at 63 percent and China at 78 percent.
By contrast, the 2018 edition of the survey found that other Arab nations dominated the top five countries seen as allies, with the exception of Russia, which ranked fourth. Neither China nor the U.S. were among the top five. The 2015 survey ranked the U.S. second.
China has shattered the assumption of U.S. dominance in the Middle East
This year’s survey, in its 15th edition, included face-to-face interviews with 3,600 Arabs aged 18 to 24 across 53 cities in 18 Arab countries, reflecting evolving sentiments prompted by a changing political landscape in the region.
While the U.S. continues to remain popular, other nations have overtaken it in ranking over the years. Turkey was found to be the country that most young Arabs considered an ally this year, at 82 percent.
Of those polled, 61 percent said they support U.S. disengagement from the Middle East, with most support for this being recorded in North Africa and the Levant.
Chinese and Saudi flags in Riyadh in December 2022.
Arab states, particularly those in the Gulf, have been frustrated at what they see as the U.S.’s waning interest in the region, and have in recent years begun charting their own foreign policy. They have refused to take sides in the Ukraine war and have grown closer to China, insisting that the world is moving towards multipolarity.
61 percent said they support U.S. disengagement from the Middle East, with most support for this being recorded in North Africa and the Levant.
Arab states, particularly those in the Gulf, have been frustrated at what they see as the U.S.’s waning interest in the region, and have in recent years begun charting their own foreign policy.
“The perception that the U.S. is strategically pivoting away from the Middle East seems to be trickling down from governments to citizens in the region,” said Anna Jacobs, a senior Gulf analyst at the International Crisis Group think tank. “But this perception should be taken with a grain of salt. U.S. soft power and its role as a security guarantor in the region is nowhere close to being replaced by other global powers like China or Russia.”
Young Arabs realize that, according to the survey. Despite the rise in China’s popularity, two-thirds still believe the U.S. will be a “more important ally” than China and Russia over the next five years.
Analysts say that the U.S.’ Middle East policy continues to be unpopular in the region, particularly its support for Israel, which the survey found is consistently ranked as the number one “enemy” among respondents.
Charles Dunne, a former U.S. diplomat who served in the Middle East, told CNN that as perceptions of the U.S.’ moral and leadership roles in the regions may have diminished, he was “surprised the U.S. ranked as high as it did.”
“Its recent diplomatic forays in the region, however, suggest China sees the U.S. role there as being in relative decline, and is seeking opportunities to exert influence and build its own influence at American expense,” he said.
Venturing into diplomacy
Unlike the U.S., Beijing presents its agenda in the region with a focus on the economy and no strings attached. A 4,000-word joint statement between Saudi Arabia and China in December affirmed they would “defend the principle of non-interference in the internal affairs of states, rules of international law and basic principles of international relations.”
China has grown to be the largest trading partner of the region’s oil exporting states. Its trade with Saudi Arabia went from $4.1 billion in 2001 to $87.3 billion in 2021 – more than the U.S. and the EU combined.
“The Middle East is already an arena of .US.-China competition, but regional actors have made it clear that they will not be cornered into choosing a side in great power competition,” Jacobs said. “They have too many interests in both the East and the West and feel they must maintain balanced relations with all the great powers.”
Dignitaries, including Chinese leader Xi Jinping and Saudi Crown Prince Mohammed bin Salman (center), at the China-Arab States Summit in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia in December 2022. – File photo
Traditionally an economic player in the region, Beijing has however begun venturing into Middle East diplomacy, long seen as an American domain.
China scored a diplomatic victory in March when it brokered a peace agreement between long-time rivals Iran and Saudi Arabia.
China scored a diplomatic victory in March when it brokered a peace agreement between long-time rivals Iran and Saudi Arabia. In April, China offered to mediate between Israel and the Palestinians.
In April, China offered to mediate between Israel and the Palestinians. And just last week, it welcomed Palestinian Authority President Mahmoud Abbas with full military honors during his four-day state visit to China. Abbas is yet to visit the White House under the Biden presidency. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has also not yet been invited since returning to office in December.
“Biden has apparently abandoned the traditional U.S. role as an honest broker,” Dunne said. “This retreat to a traditionalist Middle East policy… seems to me an acknowledgment that the president has enough problems – a hostile Congress, a tough re-election fight, the war in Ukraine, confrontation with China and a domestic agenda that needs a lot of work – to take on a lot of new ones.”
The country whose reputation has suffered the most since last year’s survey is Russia, which fell to the rank of nine among nations Arab youth consider an ally, from third last year. It also ranks third among those countries Arabs consider an enemy this year, replacing the U.S., which held that position last year but now ranks fifth. Israel (86 percent) and Iran (57 percent) ranked highest as countries Arabs consider an enemy.
Russia’s involvement in conflicts across the Middle East may be responsible for the drop in its popularity, Jacobs said. “Their invasion of Ukraine seems to have exacerbated this.”
– Written for CNN by and
Leave a Reply